Supporters of Alberta’s separatist movement are not only thrilled to have seemingly collected the necessary 177,000 signatures to trigger a referendum but are also celebrating the timing of this milestone.
Stay Free Alberta announced this achievement a week before an Edmonton judge is set to hear a First Nation’s request for an injunction against the citizens’ initiative on April 7, asserting that the quest for independence could breach Indigenous treaties.
An observer of the legal and political landscape might find it puzzling. After all, even if the signatures were gathered, an injunction from the Sturgeon Lake Cree Nation could halt the entire process managed by Elections Alberta for validating and approving the petition.
Nevertheless, this situation might provide separatist leader Mitch Sylvestre with a backup plan: directly urging Premier Danielle Smith to include the referendum on the ballot for October, irrespective of the court’s decision.
“Let’s secure the signatures before the 7th, before they can approach the court, and declare: we have fulfilled our part,” Sylvestre told CBC News. “We’ve adhered to the rules thus far.”
For Sylvestre, having the legally mandated number of petition signatures is a strategy to safeguard his group’s position against potential legal challenges.
“We don’t necessarily need to submit the signatures to Elections Alberta,” Sylvestre stated. “We have alternative routes. We could present them to the government for verification instead.”

Mitch Sylvestre leads Stay Free Alberta, the organization spearheading the independence petition and referendum. He is also a prominent UCP organizer. (Jason Markusoff/CBC)
According to the Citizen Initiative Act, a successful petition must be submitted to Elections Alberta (refer to Section 10 for specifics). However, Sylvestre’s envisioned scenario would involve circumventing the law governing citizen petitions entirely.
There are two avenues for a referendum to be included on the ballot: through a successful petition campaign conducted by Albertans, or via a government directive under the Referendum Act — the approach Smith has utilized to introduce nine additional ballot questions this fall regarding immigration and federal constitutional reform.
“The premier can initiate this whenever she chooses, with or without the [petition],” Sylvestre mentioned in a YouTube interview last month.
The interviewer clarified with Sylvestre: “We will still conduct a referendum if the premier calls for it, just to clarify.” Sylvestre responded: “I would fully expect it to proceed.”
Sturgeon Lake Cree Nation Chief Sheldon Sunshine expresses concern that Smith may find a way to bypass any judicial setback for the separatists.
“Throughout this process, we’ve observed that the UCP has been overly accommodating to this small faction,” Sunshine stated in an interview.
Sylvestre’s petition has previously faced legal defeat. In December, a different King’s Bench judge determined that separatism could not be pursued under the Citizen Initiative Act, partly due to its conflict with the Constitution and its potential to infringe upon Indigenous treaty rights.
However, the Smith administration sidestepped that judicial ruling by modifying the law to eliminate Elections Alberta’s authority to have courts evaluate the legality of a proposed referendum, thus allowing the separatist group to refile their petition as if the previous ruling never occurred.

Chief Sheldon Sunshine of Sturgeon Lake Cree Nation addresses the legislature in March, as fellow chiefs, band councillors, and elders urge Premier Danielle Smith’s government to halt the drive for the province’s exit from Canada.
(Jason Franson/The Canadian Press)
This marked the second instance in which the UCP government utilized legislation to facilitate a successful petition campaign.
In May, shortly after the Carney Liberals claimed victory in the federal elections, Justice Minister Mickey Amery introduced a bill to significantly reduce the required number of signatures for a constitutional referendum petition — from 587,952 to 177,732.
The reforms enacted by the UCP mean Sylvestre’s group now needs support from merely six percent of the provincial electorate, down from the previous requirement of 20 percent.
While Smith has consistently asserted her backing for a united Canada (with enhanced autonomy for her province), she is politically inclined to give considerable leeway to the movement advocating for separation.
Despite surveys consistently indicating that only about 20 percent or 25 percent of Albertans favor leaving Canada, the notion is more popular among UCP supporters. A faction of her party’s activist base is driving the petition efforts, including Sylvestre, a UCP riding president in northeastern Alberta.
CBC News inquired whether Smith and Amery would endorse the referendum even if an injunction halted the citizen initiative. The response from Amery’s spokesperson suggested a willingness to consider the idea.
“The independence petition has until May 2 to gather their signatures,” Heather Jenkins’s statement begins. “We’ll monitor the progression of this process and await the final signature tally from Elections Alberta once the verification period concludes.”
This indicates that Amery intends to let the procedure unfold according to the current legal framework. However, Jenkins added: “The premier has indicated that any existing citizen initiative that meets the necessary signature count will be included on the October 19 referendum ballot.”
Sylvestre asserts that he has the required forms completed, along with numerous boxes yet to be submitted and additional canvassers still gathering support for independence. Will this be sufficient in the premier’s view?

Premier Danielle Smith, pictured with Justice Minister Mickey Amery, has stated that a referendum petition with adequate signatures will be presented to the voters in Alberta. (Emilio Avalos/Radio-Canada)
The possibility of Smith circumventing an injunction remains purely hypothetical, particularly if Sturgeon Lake’s attempt to persuade a judge next week that the changes to the petition law infringe upon treaty and constitutional rights is unsuccessful.
The injunction hearing will be succeeded by a related legal challenge from other First Nations groups next week, to be presided over by the same judge.
Orlagh O’Kelly, representing Sturgeon Lake, indicated that decisions are unlikely to be rendered immediately but are expected before the May 2 deadline for Sylvestre’s petition.
She acknowledged the potential for Smith to unilaterally call for the independence referendum. “And I suspect that will also be a matter for the court,” O’Kelly added.
Sturgeon Lake Cree Nation previously intervened during the last court loss of the separatist petition, and Chief Sunshine affirmed that his nation will “defend our rights by any means necessary.”
Sylvestre, on the other hand, remains optimistic about his ability to continue fighting within the political sphere, regardless of the outcome.
This dynamic suggests that many elements may ultimately become irrelevant in the coming weeks, including the perspectives of over 177,000 Albertans and the judgment of another King’s Bench judge.
Alberta’s separatist sentiment has resurged in recent months amid the Trump administration’s comments about the province’s future, coupled with economic and political tensions with the Canadian government. Andrew Chang explains what it would actually take to grant sovereignty to a Canadian province, and why it’s so difficult to achieve.
Images provided by The Canadian Press, Reuters, Adobe Stock and Getty Images
Tag: rewrite-pending


