A resident of Miramichi is raising concerns over the fact that the Liberal MLA representing him in the New Brunswick Legislature has blocked him on Facebook.
Caleb Donnelly claims that last fall, he was blocked by Miramichi Bay-Neguac MLA Sam Johnston after he posted inquiries on Johnston’s Facebook page regarding the expected completion date for the new Natoaganeg Crossing Bridge, which has replaced the Anderson Bridge.
Shortly after this interaction, Donnelly realized he had been blocked from Johnston’s social media account.
“It feels like a lack of transparency,” Donnelly stated. “I find it odd that I would be blocked after merely asking a straightforward question.
“I considered it to be a direct inquiry, a simple Yes or No. I certainly wasn’t trying to attack him. It was just a question stemming from genuine curiosity.”
The provincial government announced last October that it would expedite the completion of the new bridge following an incident that rendered the old bridge unusable.

A constituent expresses that Sam Johnston, MLA for Miramichi Bay-Neguac, has blocked him on Facebook. (Jacques Poitras/CBC)
This closure required drivers to take a detour of 29 kilometers.
In a screenshot shared by Donnelly, he inquires about the timeline for the bridge’s completion prior to the accident.
“Why? What difference does it make now?” Johnston replied.
Donnelly responded by suggesting that “some individuals might believe” that the Holt Liberals were claiming credit for the expedited bridge completion due to the accident.
“Regardless, it’s encouraging to see progress.”
Johnston indeed took credit in the legislature on November 4.
“This government has successfully opened the new bridge, providing the good citizens of Miramichi with improved access in and out of our region,” he stated.
Donnelly mentioned that initially he thought there might have been an error, prompting him to send emails to Johnston, Premier Susan Holt, and Liberal caucus chair Natacha Vautour, but he did not receive any replies.
Johnston, who is serving his first term as an MLA and identifies himself as a “public figure” on his Facebook page, did not make himself available for an interview with CBC News regarding the blocking incident involving Donnelly.
His Facebook page refers to “online community guidelines” established by the provincial Liberals, which state that “thoughtful and respectful dialogue” is encouraged, while profanity, personal attacks, and discriminatory remarks will be removed.
“Messages considered spam or trolling will also be deleted,” the guidelines indicate. “Users violating these guidelines may face a ban without prior notice.”
-
Watson changes tune on Twitter clash
-
Court orders environment minister to unblock Rebel News founder on X
Donnelly’s inquiries do not seem to violate these rules.
He volunteered for the Conservative campaign in Miramichi last year, but he maintains that this should not justify blocking him.
“If that is indeed his reason, it’s quite disheartening because elected officials ought to collaborate, regardless of their party affiliation,” he expressed.
Hannah Fulton Johnston, the chief of staff for the Liberal caucus, stated in a release that she would refrain from commenting on specific instances and that each MLA is accountable for managing their own social media accounts.
Recent legal developments indicate that Johnston might not be on firm ground with his decision to block.
In 2018, three activists in Ottawa filed a lawsuit against Mayor Jim Watson after he blocked them on X, which was previously known as Twitter.
Within a few days, Watson reversed his decision, recognizing that as a public official, he should not prevent constituents from accessing his communications in his capacity as mayor.
In 2023, Steven Guilbeault, while serving as the federal environment minister, consented to a court order stating that he could not block Rebel News from following his X account.
Some members of the Liberal party utilize Facebook to engage with New Brunswick citizens, even on sensitive subjects.
In a year-end interview with CBC News last December, Holt expressed her openness to a comment made on her Facebook page that suggested an alternative location for the proposed Tantramar gas plant.


