Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Latest Posts

CRA’s Audit of Muslim Charity Criticized as “Seriously Deficient

A recent report from a specialist in extremist financing and money laundering criticizes the Canada Revenue Agency’s (CRA) handling of terrorist abuse allegations, stating that it was “seriously deficient” during the extensive audit of the Muslim Association of Canada (MAC).

The analysis conducted by Michelle Gallant, a professor at the University of Manitoba, is the latest in a series of recommendations urging the revenue agency to reform its auditing practices for charitable organizations to eliminate bias and discrimination.

Gallant’s report suggests that the CRA should enhance its understanding of various cultures and religions, including Islam, improve transparency regarding its auditing processes, and consider periodically releasing lists of associations and individuals that charities should avoid.

The Muslim Association, which engaged in legal proceedings to halt the CRA’s audit, commissioned Gallant for this review. She clarified that she did not receive payment for her work and had no previous connections to either the charity or the CRA.

Known as MAC, the association focuses on community service, education, and youth empowerment, claiming that over 150,000 Canadians utilize its mosques, schools, and community centers annually.

MAC has consistently argued that the CRA’s Review and Analysis Division’s audit of its operations, initiated in 2015, was fundamentally flawed due to systemic bias and Islamophobia.

During the litigation regarding the agency’s audit, government lawyers indicated that initial findings from the audit revealed “several serious issues” related to the association’s failure to comply with its charitable registration obligations.

These issues reportedly involved participation in foreign political activities, the acquisition of significant real estate, providing aid to a group classified as a terrorist organization, and the issuance of improper donation receipts.

According to Gallant’s report, the scrutiny regarding support for extremism places charities “in the unenviable position of making decisions about what actors, or actions, the administrator of charities law might think are linked to terrorism.”

“Despite the distinctive ambitions of the administrative agency — the effort to police terrorist abuse — in the case of the MAC audit that effort proved seriously deficient,” she concluded.

Risk of ”guilt by association’: report

Gallant noted that the agency relied significantly on MAC’s associations and connections in its assessment.

“Considerable dispute exists over the implications and effectiveness of such ‘links,’ or associational, methods,” she stated.

“It risks capturing innocent activity through associational connections, risks ‘over-inclusion’ and can fail to accurately discern between suspicious activity and authentic legitimate activity.”

The report emphasizes that leaders of Muslim charities, as well as their volunteers and employees, are part of their religious communities.

“Any suggestion that associations — connections — indicate terrorist abuse risks overidentification and the imposition of ‘guilt’ by association,” it warns.

Gallant mentioned that the CRA could enhance its role in educating charities about the potential risks associated with certain groups or individuals.

“I believe if the charities directorate was more forthcoming in educating — specifically advising against interactions or activities that raise suspicions — then charities could make informed decisions,” she said.

Nina Ioussoupova, a spokesperson for the revenue agency, declined to comment on Gallant’s suggestions, stating that the charities directorate “does not comment on third-party reports.”

A report from the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency released in October highlighted “a lack of rigor” in how the agency selects charities for audits regarding terrorism concerns, pointing out that the process carries risks of bias and discrimination.

In response to the intelligence watchdog’s findings, the revenue agency asserted its commitment to ensuring that registered charities are treated equitably and without bias. The agency also acknowledged most of the watchdog’s recommendations and indicated that it had already begun to improve its processes and oversight.

The federal taxpayers’ ombudsperson’s office recently stated that the revenue agency is “taking significant steps” to enhance awareness among its employees of “unconscious bias” that may lead to discriminatory actions.

MAC remains registered charity

MAC sought an injunction from the Ontario Superior Court to halt the CRA’s audit, arguing that it infringed upon Charter of Rights protections for equality and freedom of religion, expression, and association.

A judge determined in 2023 that it was premature to intervene in the federal examination, a ruling that was upheld on appeal.

MAC asserts that its charitable status was neither suspended nor revoked as a result of the CRA audit.

The association reports that it entered into a compliance agreement regarding “technical governance issues,” resulting in minor financial penalties that are currently under appeal.

Ioussoupova refrained from commenting on the audit, explaining that the revenue agency’s actions can only be disclosed when an audit leads to the revocation, annulment, or suspension of charitable registration, or when a charity faces penalties.

She confirmed that MAC remains a registered charity.

Sharaf Sharafeldin, MAC’s president for strategy, expressed that Gallant’s review “brings meaningful closure to Canadians, particularly the Canadian Muslim community.”

“We anticipate the audit being formally concluded soon and remain dedicated to serving our communities and providing strong and principled leadership for Canadian Muslims.”

Latest Posts

Don't Miss