A Coquitlam, British Columbia RCMP constable appeared at a hearing to defend himself against potential dismissal from the force due to derogatory remarks made in group chats with fellow officers. In a recent ruling, RCMP adjudicator Louise Morel determined that Constables Philip Dick, Ian Solven, and Mersad Mesbah had demonstrated disrespect and incivility towards individuals in online chats and police computer communications.
The focus of the hearing was primarily on Mesbah’s behavior. The representative for the RCMP’s conduct authority, John MacLaughlan, argued for Mesbah’s immediate dismissal or a 14-day ultimatum to resign. However, Mesbah’s lawyer, Allison Tremblay, contended that rehabilitation measures could salvage his relationship with the RCMP rather than termination.
MacLaughlan emphasized that Mesbah’s actions were fundamentally incompatible with the duties of a police officer, advocating for dismissal as the only appropriate course of action to uphold public trust in the RCMP. He highlighted that Mesbah had already been suspended longer than his tenure as an active member.
Specific instances of misconduct by Mesbah were addressed, including his use of offensive language towards colleagues and expressing disturbing sentiments while on duty. Mesbah expressed regret for his words, stating that he would not have acted on them.
During his testimony, Mesbah shared details of his background, education, and career in law enforcement. He mentioned a shift in the work environment that led to negative feelings, which he sought to release through the group chats. Mesbah acknowledged personal growth and anger management through counseling, attributing it in part to his role as a father of two daughters.
Tremblay proposed alternative consequences for Mesbah’s actions, such as a pay reduction or additional training. All three Coquitlam constables, including Mesbah, were placed on suspension with pay following the incident. A final decision from Morel is expected on January 13.
