A legal action contesting the tariffs imposed by U.S. President Donald Trump on Canada has been initiated in the United States Court of International Trade.
The suit, lodged on Tuesday by the non-profit Liberty Justice Center representing U.S. food importer Gellert Global Group, contends that Trump’s application of a trade statute from the Great Depression surpasses his presidential authority.
“Employing Section 338, which, in my view, is an inactive statute from 1930 that has never been previously utilized, just indicated to us that this is incorrect and we should take action,” stated Liberty Justice Center CEO Sara Albrecht during an interview from Chicago with CBC’s Katie Simpson.
In August, Trump invoked Section 338 to impose a 50 percent tax on a variety of Canadian goods after trade negotiations failed.
The same statute was subsequently used in the following month to prohibit the import of additional Canadian products, including motorcycles and certain alcohol and dairy items.
Lawsuit claims Canadian policies fail to warrant tariffs
The White House has asserted that Section 338 grants the president the authority to implement tariffs when a nation places U.S. exporters at a disadvantage compared to exporters in other nations — even though this law has never been applied for such reasons.
U.S. officials have indicated that the recent tariffs are a reaction to provincial restrictions on U.S. liquor, Canada’s controlled dairy system, and quotas on specific U.S. vehicles.
The lawsuit filed on Tuesday claims that the Canadian policies do not justify the extensive tariffs enforced by the Trump administration.
-
Trump says ‘very bad’ Canada is being ‘taught a little lesson’ as trade action escalates
-
Fact-checking the White House statement of facts about Canada
It highlights that two of the actions — auto quotas and liquor bans — were actually a reaction to Trump’s own tariff initiatives.
Additionally, the lawsuit mentions that Canada’s dairy supply management consists of policies established under the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement on trade, known as CUSMA, which was negotiated during Trump’s first term.
“This has real-world ramifications not just for importers but for consumers in both nations,” Albrecht remarked. “And I believe it also has wider implications considering the nature of our two countries and our historical ties.”
She acknowledged that tariffs are a hallmark of Trump’s policies but argued that their application in this instance is inappropriate.
“He has consistently favored tariffs, in my opinion, mainly because they generate revenue… I can appreciate that,” Albrecht stated. “However, in this situation, it’s incorrect and infringes upon our Constitution.”
A representative from the Trump administration indicated that the president’s actions will be robustly defended in court. The official stated that the lawsuit filed on Tuesday will not sway the president’s dedication to ensuring fairness for American workers, farmers, and businesses.
Concerns extend beyond Canada
However, the actions of the Trump administration are resulting in repercussions for American enterprises.
Thomas Gellert, co-CEO of Gellert Global Group, noted that the company has “spent generations cultivating trusted relationships with suppliers, customers, and partners throughout the food sector.”
“These tariffs abruptly disrupt those relationships and generate costs and uncertainty that reverberate throughout the entire supply chain,” Gellert explained in a statement.
The firm is facing the impacts of the trade conflict from multiple angles. It incurs a 50 percent tariff on the importation of Canadian cheese while simultaneously being affected by Ottawa’s retaliatory tariffs on American-made cheeses that its Canadian branch sells in Canada.
The company points to one of its Canadian cheese suppliers to illustrate how the interconnected North American market is being affected by the tariff conflict. It sources milk from dairy farmers in Upstate New York, processes it into brie in Canada, and then ships it back to the United States.
“The tariffs impact American farmers and businesses on both sides of that transaction,” the statement noted.
The situation raises alarms that extend beyond Canada, according to the statement. If the tariffs continue unchecked, any future president could invoke Section 338 to impose tariffs and trade barriers without significant congressional oversight.
The lawsuit seeks a court ruling declaring the tariffs illegal and demanding a refund.
The Liberty Justice Center previously participated in the legal challenge against Trump’s invocation of the International Economic Emergency Powers Act of 1977 concerning the so-called “Liberation Day” and tariffs on fentanyl-related products from Canada, Mexico, and China.
In February, the highest court in the United States determined that it was unlawful for Trump to utilize the statute, known as IEEPA, since the U.S. Constitution explicitly grants Congress authority over taxes and tariffs.


